CAT AGI Knowledge base report 3.
Profile: Kakha Kaladze

The System Mayor: An Analytical Profile of Kakha Kaladze and the Operationalization of Power in Tbilisi

This report analyzes the governance model of Tbilisi’s mayor, documenting how a fusion of celebrity, administrative power, and corporate patronage operationalizes the ruling system at the municipal level. It is the third foundational briefing from the CAT AGI Knowledge Base.

Attribution and Disclaimer:
Analysis by: Miraziz Bazarov, CAT AGI Founder.
Methodology: This report is a preliminary analysis (v1.02 - NOUS VERSION) based on open-source intelligence (OSINT), AI-assisted data processing, and initial findings. It will be updated and expanded with data gathered from our “Transparency Log” of official information requests, direct open and anonymous interviews, and information submitted by citizens via the catagi.ge platform.
Last Updated: 23 September 2025

Executive Summary

This report documents and analyzes the political career, governance model, and key networks of Kakha Kaladze, the Mayor of Tbilisi. The analysis reveals a figure who has successfully transitioned from a celebrated international football champion into a central and resilient pillar of Georgia's ruling establishment. His trajectory illustrates a potent fusion of celebrity appeal, substantial personal wealth, and disciplined political loyalty, which has enabled him to consolidate significant power within the country's capital.

The report documents Kaladze’s dual role as both the technocratic manager of Tbilisi and a loyal enforcer of the Georgian Dream (GD) party’s political agenda, a position formally solidified by his long-standing role as the party's Secretary-General. This duality allows him to cultivate a public image of a pragmatic, results-oriented urban administrator, often distinct from the more polarizing figures of the national government, while simultaneously executing the strategic directives of the party's informal leader, Bidzina Ivanishvili.

The core of this analysis examines the “Kaladze Model” of governance, a system characterized by the deep integration of the formal administrative hierarchy of the Tbilisi Mayor’s Office with informal networks of political patronage and corporate interests. The data indicates a consistent pattern where municipal resources, particularly through public procurement, are channeled towards companies with documented financial and personal ties to the ruling party and the mayor’s inner circle. This creates a self-perpetuating loop of economic and political power that reinforces the regime's control at the municipal level.

The report profiles the key figures within Kaladze’s administration, documenting a team built not on open competition but on long-standing personal and political loyalty, with many of his top deputies having worked with him since his tenure as Minister of Energy. This insular structure ensures disciplined execution of his agenda but also fosters an environment where transparency and accountability are systematically diminished.

Finally, this audit encapsulates the systemic challenges associated with his administration. These include documented cases of high-level conflicts of interest, the systematic use of administrative leverage to enforce political loyalty within the civil service, and an increasingly confrontational stance towards civic and media dissent. Kaladze’s mayoralty, therefore, serves as a critical case study in how the broader system of informal, oligarchic governance in Georgia is operationalized at the municipal level, directly impacting democratic processes and urban development in the nation's capital.

1. Introduction: The Mayor as a Systemic Pillar

The analysis of Kakha Kaladze’s tenure as Mayor of Tbilisi is not undertaken as a standalone political biography. Instead, this report frames his administration as a crucial case study for the foundational mission of the CAT AGI project: to document and understand the operational mechanics of power in contemporary Georgia. The Tbilisi Mayor’s Office, under Kaladze’s leadership, provides a granular, municipal-level illustration of the principles of informal governance and systemic state capture that have been previously analyzed in the context of the system’s architect, Bidzina Ivanishvili.

While previous reports in this “Knowledge Base” series have detailed the national-level architecture of power, this analysis drills down to the point of implementation. It examines how the abstract concepts of administrative leverage, narrative control, and the fusion of corporate and state interests are translated into concrete policies and practices that directly shape the lives of over a million citizens in the nation's capital. Tbilisi is not merely Georgia’s largest city; it is its political, economic, and cultural nucleus. Control over its municipal apparatus, budget, and public spaces is therefore a strategic imperative for any ruling power.

By examining the specific mechanisms of control, patronage, and public narrative management deployed by the Tbilisi Mayor’s Office, we can gain a deeper understanding of how the national power vertical is operationalized, sustained, and legitimized. The patterns of procurement, the criteria for personnel appointments, the response to civic protest, and the management of media narratives within the city’s domain are not isolated municipal issues. They are reflections of the broader systemic logic that governs the state. This report, therefore, documents Kaladze not just as a mayor, but as a systemic pillar whose governance model is integral to the resilience and functioning of the entire ruling structure, particularly in shaping the pre-election environment and managing public consent in the country's most critical urban center.

2. From Football Champion to Political Powerhouse: The Trajectory of Kakha Kaladze

The political ascent of Kakha Kaladze is inextricably linked to the immense social capital he accumulated during a storied international football career. His transformation from a national sports hero into a key political operative for the Georgian Dream party is a case study in the conversion of celebrity into political power, a journey shaped by personal tragedy, strategic business investments, and a pivotal alliance with Georgia's informal ruler, Bidzina Ivanishvili.

2.1. Early Life and Sporting Apex

Kakhaber “Kakha” Kaladze was born on February 27, 1978, in Samtredia, a town in the Imereti region of what was then the Georgian SSR. His father, Karlo Kaladze, was a footballer and president of the local club, Lokomotiv Samtredia, immersing him in the sport from a young age. Kaladze began his professional career at just 16, debuting for Georgia's premier club, Dinamo Tbilisi, in 1993. During his tenure from 1993 to 1998, he played 82 matches and won five Georgian league titles, quickly establishing himself as one of the country's most promising talents.
His international career began in earnest with a move to the Ukrainian powerhouse Dynamo Kyiv in 1998, where he won three consecutive league titles and gained significant international exposure. The defining moment of his sporting career came in 2001, when the Italian giant AC Milan acquired him for a transfer fee of €16 million, making him the most expensive Georgian footballer in history.

His nine-year tenure at AC Milan (2001–2010) was the foundation of his national hero status. As a versatile and reliable defender for one of the world's most prestigious clubs, he achieved the highest honors in European football. He won the UEFA Champions League twice, in 2003 and 2007, becoming the first and only Georgian player to do so. His list of accolades with Milan also includes a Serie A title (2004), a Coppa Italia (2003), a UEFA Super Cup (2003, 2007), and a FIFA Club World Cup (2007). He served as captain of the Georgian national team for many years, making 84 appearances between 1996 and 2011. After leaving Milan, he played for two seasons at the Italian club Genoa before officially announcing his retirement from football on May 12, 2012. This illustrious career provided him with immense public recognition, a reputation for discipline and success, and significant personal wealth—assets that would prove invaluable in his subsequent political career.

2.2. The Family Tragedy

Kaladze’s professional success was overshadowed by a profound personal tragedy that became a defining event in his life and shaped his relationship with the Georgian state. In May 2001, shortly after his celebrated move to Milan, his younger brother Levan, a medical student, was kidnapped in Tbilisi by criminals demanding a large ransom. The case garnered massive public attention, but the investigation by the authorities under President Eduard Shevardnadze's government was widely seen as inept and ineffective.

Despite the family’s efforts and Kaladze’s international appeals, Levan was never found alive. For years, his fate remained unknown. At one point, in protest against the authorities’ perceived inaction, Kaladze considered renouncing his place on the national team, a move that would have been a significant blow to the country’s morale. He ultimately decided against it, but the experience instilled in him a deep distrust of the state institutions of that era. In 2006, five years after the kidnapping, Levan was officially declared dead, and two individuals were later convicted for his murder and sentenced to a combined 30 years in prison. This traumatic event, and the state’s failure to protect his family, is a critical element of his biography, providing a personal subtext to his later decision to join a political movement aimed at overthrowing the established political order.

2.3. Entry into Business and Philanthropy

Even before retiring from football, Kaladze began strategically planning for his post-sporting life by venturing into business. In 2008, he founded Kala Capital, a Georgia-based investment company. Significantly, he appointed Zurab Noghaideli, who had served as Prime Minister of Georgia from 2005 to 2007, as the company’s CEO, immediately giving his business venture political weight and high-level connections. Kala Capital’s portfolio focused on energy, banking, and real estate, with investments in Georgia, Ukraine, Italy, and Kazakhstan.

His business interests extended to the hospitality sector. He opened an upscale Buddha Bar in Kyiv in 2008 and acquired the historic, Michelin-starred restaurant Giannino in Milan. These ventures were not just financial investments; they were part of a deliberate effort to build a brand as a sophisticated, successful international businessman, moving beyond his identity as an athlete. In parallel, he engaged in philanthropy, establishing the Kala Foundation in 2008. The foundation was involved in charitable activities, including providing aid to refugees displaced during the 2008 Russo-Georgian War, which further enhanced his public profile as a patriotic figure.

2.4. The Political Ascent (2012-2017)

In February 2012, shortly before his official retirement from football, Kaladze made a decisive entry into politics by joining the nascent opposition movement, Georgian Dream, founded by billionaire Bidzina Ivanishvili. As one of the most famous and respected public figures in the country, his endorsement provided Ivanishvili's coalition with immediate and widespread popular legitimacy. He ran in the October 1, 2012 parliamentary elections and won the majoritarian seat for his native Samtredia district.

Following Georgian Dream’s landmark victory, Kaladze’s rise within the new government was meteoric. On October 25, 2012, Prime Minister Ivanishvili appointed him to the powerful dual positions of Vice Prime Minister and Minister of Energy and Natural Resources. This appointment immediately triggered a major controversy over a conflict of interest. At the time, his company, Kala Capital, held a 45% stake in SakHidroEnergoMsheni, a major player in Georgia’s hydropower construction sector. Facing intense scrutiny from civil society and political opponents, Kaladze pledged to divest his energy assets. In November 2012, Kala Capital sold its shares to a company named GMC Group, though questions about his indirect influence in the sector persisted.

As Minister of Energy, a position he held until 2017 under three successive prime ministers, Kaladze oversaw Georgia’s energy policy, including sensitive and controversial negotiations with Russia’s state-owned gas monopoly, Gazprom, regarding the terms of gas transit to Armenia. This five-year period served as his political apprenticeship, transforming him from a celebrity recruit into an experienced cabinet member and a core figure within the Georgian Dream leadership. In 2013, he was also appointed Secretary-General of the party, a position that cemented his role as a key organizational leader and a loyal lieutenant to Ivanishvili.

2.5. Mayor of Tbilisi (2017-Present)

In July 2017, Kaladze resigned from his ministerial posts to become the Georgian Dream candidate for Mayor of Tbilisi. Leveraging his immense popularity and the party's administrative resources, he won the election decisively in the first round on October 22, 2017, securing approximately 51% of the vote. He was sworn into office on November 13, 2017.

His first term was defined by a focus on large-scale urban infrastructure projects, including a comprehensive overhaul of the city’s bus fleet, the rehabilitation of major avenues, and the adoption of a new General Land Use Plan to regulate construction. These visible projects helped him build a reputation as an effective and modernizing city manager. In the October 2021 municipal elections, he was re-elected for a second term, defeating his opponent in the second round with 55.6% of the vote.

His second term has been marked by escalating political polarization and a series of major crises. In July 2021, his public statement that the planned Tbilisi Pride march was “inexpedient” was widely criticized for emboldening violent far-right groups who subsequently attacked journalists and activists, forcing the event's cancellation. In October 2022, the city was shaken by the Vake Park tragedy, where a 13-year-old girl was fatally electrocuted in a newly renovated fountain, exposing severe negligence in the city’s procurement and oversight systems.

Most recently, Kaladze has become a target of international censure. In December 2024, following a violent crackdown on pro-European protests, Ukraine, Lithuania, and Estonia imposed personal sanctions on him and other high-ranking Georgian Dream officials for their role in undermining democracy. His response was defiant and echoed the party's anti-Western rhetoric, accusing Ukrainian President Zelenskyy of “serving another country”. In a symbolic rebuke, Ukraine's Ministry of Sport revoked his honorary title of “Master of Sports of International Class” in February 2025. Despite these controversies, he remains a dominant political figure, and in 2025, he announced his intention to seek an unprecedented third term as mayor in the upcoming elections.

2.6. Career Timeline

Period	Stage of Career and Achievements
1993–2001	Player for Dinamo Tbilisi and Dynamo Kyiv; won five Georgian and three Ukrainian championships
2001–2010	Defender for AC Milan; won the Italian championship and was a two-time UEFA Champions League winner
2012	Retired from sports; joined Bidzina Ivanishvili's opposition movement, Georgian Dream
2012–2017	Vice Prime Minister and Minister of Energy of Georgia; divested from energy assets to address conflict of interest concerns
Oct 2017	Elected Mayor of Tbilisi with 51% of the vote in the first round
Oct 2021	Re-elected Mayor of Tbilisi with 55.6% of the vote in the second round
Dec 2024	Sanctioned by Ukraine and Baltic states as a key associate of the Ivanishvili system
2025	Incumbent Mayor of Tbilisi, planning to run for a third term

3. The Kaladze Model: An Analysis of Municipal Governance and Influence

The governance of Tbilisi under Kakha Kaladze is not merely an exercise in public administration; it is the implementation of a distinct political model. This model is characterized by the co-existence of a formal, hierarchical bureaucracy with a parallel, more influential network of informal power. It leverages administrative resources for political ends, intertwines municipal procurement with corporate patronage, and deploys a sophisticated public relations strategy to manage a dual identity: that of a modern, technocratic manager and a hardline party loyalist. An analysis of this model provides a clear window into how the ruling system operates at the crucial municipal level. This section deconstructs the operational mechanics of Kaladze's authority, arguing that his power is a product of his unique position at the intersection of a formal bureaucracy and a more decisive informal power vertical.

3.1. The Dual Mandate: Party Secretary and City Manager

The foundation of Kakha Kaladze’s political power rests on a strategic synergy between two distinct but complementary roles: the seemingly apolitical, results-oriented manager of Georgia’s capital city and the disciplined, high-ranking enforcer of the ruling party's national agenda. His long-standing position as Secretary-General of Georgian Dream is not an incidental detail but a core component of his authority, providing him with direct access to the party's central decision-making apparatus and a clear mandate to align municipal governance with the party's strategic objectives. This duality allows him to navigate Georgia's polarized political landscape with a unique versatility, projecting different personas to different audiences as politically required.

To the citizens of Tbilisi, Kaladze frequently presents himself as a modern, pragmatic administrator focused on tangible urban improvements. His public communications often center on infrastructure projects, transport reform, and urban renewal—issues that resonate with the daily concerns of the capital's residents. This technocratic focus allows him to cultivate a brand that is often perceived as less partisan and more competent than that of his more overtly political colleagues in the national government. However, when the ruling party’s core interests are challenged, the polished facade of the city manager recedes, and the disciplined party loyalist emerges. In these moments, Kaladze becomes a key defender of the national party line, vocally supporting controversial policies such as the “foreign agent” law and echoing the government's anti-Western rhetoric, which often frames external criticism as an attack by a “global war party”.

This dual role is not a contradiction but a highly effective political strategy that addresses a fundamental challenge for the Georgian Dream regime: maintaining its grip on Tbilisi. The capital's electorate, which includes a significant concentration of urban youth, middle-class professionals, and civil society actors, is often more liberal and skeptical of the government's conservative and increasingly illiberal turn than the party's traditional base in the regions. Kaladze's carefully managed persona—a successful, internationally recognized figure with a European sense of style—is tailored to appeal to this specific demographic. By delivering visible, high-profile projects and maintaining a brand of modern competence, he provides a more palatable face for the ruling party in its most critical and electorally vulnerable constituency. He functions as a “brand ambassador” for the regime, bridging the gap between the party's national platform and the distinct political culture of the capital, thereby making the entire system more resilient.

3.2. Formal Hierarchy vs. Informal Networks: Deconstructing the Power Vertical

To understand how power is exercised in Tbilisi, one must analyze the dual structures through which Kaladze operates. On one hand, there is the official, public-facing organigram of the Tbilisi Mayor's Office, a formal bureaucracy with a clear chain of command. On the other, there is a less visible but more decisive network of political and economic allegiances that underpins and magnifies his authority. His effective power is a product of his unique position at the intersection of these two systems.

The Formal Structure
The de jure structure of governance is the administrative framework through which the city is officially managed. At its apex is Mayor Kaladze, followed by a First Vice-Mayor and several Deputy Mayors, each overseeing specific portfolios. Below them lies the bureaucratic apparatus of the municipal departments, or City Services, which are responsible for implementing policy in areas such as Infrastructure Development, Finance, Municipal Procurement, and Security. This formal structure provides the legal and administrative basis for his actions, from budget allocation to project implementation.

The Informal Network
Parallel to this formal hierarchy exists a de facto network of influence that constitutes the true source of Kaladze’s political power. This network is built on four primary external connections:
1. Patronage & Strategic Direction: The most critical connection is to Bidzina Ivanishvili, the founder and informal leader of Georgian Dream. This relationship is the ultimate source of Kaladze's political mandate and strategic guidance. His public statements consistently affirm his loyalty to Ivanishvili, framing him as a historic figure who saved the country from the previous regime and continues to act in the national interest. This allegiance ensures that Kaladze's actions as mayor are aligned with the broader strategic objectives of the system's architect.
2. Party Line & Political Discipline: As Secretary-General, Kaladze is deeply integrated with the formal leadership of the Georgian Dream party, including figures like Prime Minister Irakli Kobakhidze. This connection ensures that the municipal government operates as a disciplined extension of the national party apparatus, enforcing the party line on key political issues and mobilizing administrative resources in support of the party's electoral goals.
3. Economic Interests & Patronage Loop: Kaladze’s office maintains a symbiotic relationship with a network of key business allies and contractors who are frequent beneficiaries of municipal tenders. As will be detailed in Part II of this report, this creates a transactional loop where public funds are channeled to politically connected companies, which in turn provide economic and political support to the ruling party.
4. Enforcement & Control of Public Space: There is a documented operational synergy between the Mayor's Office and the state's security and law enforcement structures, including the Ministry of Internal Affairs (MIA) and the State Security Service (SUS/SGB). This coordination is most visible during periods of civil unrest, where the mayor's public rhetoric often legitimizes the forceful dispersal of protests, and municipal services are used in concert with police actions to control public spaces.

Kaladze’s capacity for governance stems from his ability to skillfully navigate and leverage both the formal bureaucracy and these informal networks simultaneously. His authority is not derived solely from his elected position but is sustained and amplified by his deep integration within the broader, informal system of oligarchic control that defines Georgia's current political landscape.

3.3. The Inner Circle: A Cadre of Loyalty

The operational effectiveness and political resilience of the Kaladze administration are rooted in a tightly knit and loyal core team. An analysis of the key figures in his orbit reveals a governance structure built on long-standing personal and professional relationships rather than open, meritocratic appointments. Many of his most influential deputies are individuals who have been with him since his tenure at the Ministry of Energy, creating an insular and disciplined inner circle that ensures the faithful execution of his agenda. This team functions not only as a municipal cabinet but also as a political cadre, deeply integrated into the broader power vertical of the Georgian Dream party.

The recent appointment of Giorgi Tkemaladze, the former Chairman of the Tbilisi City Council (Sakrebulo), as First Vice-Mayor in May 2025 marks a critical evolution in the administration's structure. This move, following the departure of his long-serving “right hand” Irakli Khmaladze, represents a significant consolidation of power. While Khmaladze represented the administrative-legal pillar of the team, Tkemaladze embodies the purely political pillar, with deep roots in the party structure and a direct line to its leadership. This transition effectively dissolves any remaining pretense of separation between the municipal executive and legislative branches, transforming the administration into a more direct and streamlined instrument of the ruling party's political will. This is not a simple personnel shuffle but a strategic re-engineering of municipal governance designed to enhance top-down control and reduce accountability by merging the legislative approval function with executive implementation power.

Key Personnel Overview

Name	Position(s) in Mayor's Office	Previous Role / Key Affiliation	Key Notes
Irakli Khmaladze	First Vice-Mayor (2017-2025)	Deputy Minister of Energy (under Kaladze)	Described as Kaladze's "right hand" and the "grey cardinal" of the administration; transferred to Deputy Minister of Justice in May 2025 following a conflict of interest scandal
Giorgi Tkemaladze	Chairman of Tbilisi City Council (2017-2025); First Vice-Mayor (2025-Present)	Long-serving GD political figure	As Sakrebulo Chairman, he was the key political enabler of Kaladze's agenda, ensuring legislative approval for all initiatives. His appointment as First Vice-Mayor marks a consolidation of political control within the executive branch
Ilia Eloshvili	Deputy Mayor (2018-2022)	Deputy Minister of Energy (under Kaladze)	A central figure from Kaladze's Ministry of Energy cohort and a close personal friend. Oversaw critical areas of municipal services until his death in 2022
Irakli Bendeliani	Deputy Mayor for Infrastructure (2017-Present)	Head of Georgian Gas Transportation Company	Perceived as the "technocrat" of the team, responsible for overseeing the city's largest and most controversial infrastructure projects, including the University-Bagebi bridge
Maia Bitadze	Deputy Mayor (2017-2020)	Deputy Minister of Environment	After serving as Deputy Mayor, she was elected to the national parliament as a GD MP, demonstrating the path of advancement for loyal team members
Andria Basilaia	Deputy Mayor for Social Policy, Education, Culture & Sport (2021-Present)	Head of Municipal Services Development Agency	Represents the "younger face" of the administration, responsible for public-facing initiatives in culture, education, and sport

3.4. Instruments of Control: Administrative Leverage and Security Coordination

A core feature of the Kaladze model is the systematic use of the municipal apparatus as an instrument for enforcing political conformity and consolidating the ruling party’s power. The principle of a neutral, professional civil service appears to have been subordinated to the requirement of absolute political loyalty, transforming public employment into a tool of control. This practice is not covert but has been articulated publicly by the mayor himself, particularly during periods of heightened political tension.

In December 2024, amid widespread pro-European protests following the government's democratic backsliding, Kaladze explicitly addressed municipal employees who had signed petitions supporting Georgia's EU integration path. He publicly characterized these actions as “sabotage” and a component of a “coup plan,” sending an unambiguous message throughout the city's bureaucracy that expressing dissent against the government's political line was incompatible with public service. These statements coincided with a broader pattern of dismissals across the public sector. A report by Transparency International Georgia documented that approximately 700 civil servants were fired nationwide during the political crisis, with a significant number of these cases occurring within the structures of the Tbilisi municipality. While official reasons often cited restructuring or performance issues, the timing and context strongly suggest that the dismissals were politically motivated, targeting individuals deemed disloyal to the ruling party’s agenda. This weaponization of public employment creates a climate of fear and self-censorship within the municipal workforce, ensuring that the vast administrative machine of the capital city operates in lockstep with the political objectives of Georgian Dream.

This internal disciplinary mechanism is complemented by a close operational synergy with state security and law enforcement agencies, particularly in the management of public space and the suppression of dissent. During major protests, the Mayor’s Office and the Ministry of Internal Affairs (MIA) have demonstrated a coordinated approach. The mayor's public statements often serve to legitimize forceful police actions by framing protesters as violent radicals or foreign-backed agents, while municipal services are deployed to clear protest sites or remove symbols of dissent. This close coordination transforms the municipal government from a provider of city services into an integral component of the state's security apparatus.

This dynamic is not unique to the capital, but its implementation in smaller cities can feel even more coercive due to the lack of anonymity. As described by a political activist in Batumi, the intimate nature of a smaller community intensifies the pressure, where personal relationships are weaponized by the state: “My classmate caught me, and my lecturer convicted me”. This on-the-ground perspective highlights the deeply personal and coercive nature of a system where the lines between state institutions, political loyalty, and personal relationships are deliberately blurred to enforce control.

4. The Patronage Loop: An Anatomy of Procurement and Corporate Interests

The pattern of awarding municipal contracts to politically connected entities in Tbilisi is not a series of isolated incidents but a manifestation of a broader, national system of state capture. Research by non-governmental organizations like Transparency International Georgia has extensively documented a “donor-contractor” symbiosis, where companies that make significant financial contributions to the ruling party are subsequently awarded lucrative state tenders. This transactional relationship creates a closed loop where public funds are effectively recycled to reinforce the political and economic dominance of the ruling elite. The cases examined within the Tbilisi municipality are microcosms of this national phenomenon, providing granular evidence of how this system is operationalized at the local level, directly impacting urban development and undermining the principles of fair competition and transparent governance.

4.1. Overview of Key Cases

Case Name	Contractor / Buyer	Documented Link to GD/Kaladze	Core Controversy
The Vake Park Tragedy (2022)	Greenservice+ LLC	Documented history of corruption and continued patronage under the GD administration	Systemic Negligence: A company with a prior conviction for tender-rigging was repeatedly awarded contracts, leading to a fatal incident due to gross negligence and faulty workmanship
Gudiashvili Square Property Sale (2024)	Business group of Ivliane Tsulaya	Tsulaya is a close personal friend and the reported best man of Mayor Kaladze	State-Funded Value Capture: Public funds were used to renovate historic properties, dramatically increasing their value, before they were sold in a non-competitive process to the mayor's close associate
University-Bagebi Bridge Tender (2021)	Construction Service LLC	Founders include a former municipal official, a former board member of Bidzina Ivanishvili's Cartu Bank, and are on-record GD party donors	The Donor-Contractor Loop: A strategic, high-value infrastructure contract was awarded to a company whose leadership is composed of political insiders and active party donors, exemplifying a transactional system of patronage

4.2. Case Study: The Vake Park Tragedy — A Systemic Failure

The tragic death of 13-year-old Marita Meparishvili, who was fatally electrocuted in a newly renovated fountain in Vake Park on October 13, 2022, was more than a tragic accident; it was a systemic failure that exposed the devastating consequences of a procurement model prioritizing political connections over public safety. The incident triggered widespread public outrage and laid bare the deep-seated cronyism and negligence within the city's contracting and oversight systems.

The primary contractor for the fountain's renovation was Greenservice+ LLC, a company with a well-documented history of corruption. The firm's founders, Lasha Purtskhvanidze and Koba Kharshiladze, were former municipal officials who had been convicted in 2013 for fraud and tender-rigging related to their predecessor company, “Greenservice”. In that case, they were found to have used their official positions to funnel landscaping contracts to their own company, which was registered under the names of acquaintances. Despite this conviction and the blacklisting of the original company, the same individuals simply re-registered under the new name “Greenservice+” and continued to win millions of GEL in municipal contracts under the Georgian Dream administration, including during Kaladze's mayoralty.

The investigation into Meparishvili’s death revealed a cascade of failures rooted in this corrupt foundation. Investigators found that during the final stages of the fountain's renovation, welders had damaged the insulation of a high-voltage electrical cable while installing a metal casing. This critical flaw went undetected due to a complete breakdown in oversight. The investigation established that Greenservice+ had presented the completed work to the City Hall's Environmental Protection Service without conducting a proper inspection, and the deputy head of the service had accepted the work without verifying its safety. Furthermore, to secure the official handover, Greenservice+ had pressured an inspection company, “Mshenexpert,” to produce a falsified report that falsely certified the project's compliance with construction norms and safety standards.

The subsequent legal proceedings confirmed the criminal nature of these failures. In July 2023, the Tbilisi City Court delivered guilty verdicts for eight of the nine defendants. Lasha Purtskhvanidze, the director of Greenservice+, was sentenced to six years in prison; the director and an inspector from Mshenexpert were each sentenced to three years and six months for falsifying documents; and the deputy head of the City Hall's Environmental Protection Service, Giorgi Vakhtangashvili, received a three-year sentence for official neglect. The verdicts provided legal validation for what was already evident: a chain of negligence and corruption directly led to a child's death.

The Vake Park tragedy serves as a stark indictment of the entire procurement system. The failure was not merely in one faulty wire but in the political and administrative decisions that allowed a known corrupt entity to continue operating with public funds. The continued patronage of Greenservice+ demonstrates a systemic logic where political loyalty and informal networks are valued more highly than formal rules, professional competence, or the safety of the city's residents. It reveals a structural inability of the system to self-correct, as its primary function appears to be the maintenance of a patronage network rather than the delivery of safe and effective public services.

4.3. Case Study: Gudiashvili Square — Leveraging Public Funds for Private Gain

The 2024 sale of four historic buildings on the prestigious Gudiashvili Square exemplifies a more sophisticated model of cronyism, one that can be described as “state-sponsored value creation for private capture”. This case reveals a multi-stage process where public funds are strategically used to de-risk and significantly inflate the value of a state asset before it is transferred through a non-competitive process to an individual from the mayor's innermost personal circle.

The first stage of this process involved a massive public investment. A municipal entity, the Tbilisi Development Fund, undertook a large-scale rehabilitation project for Gudiashvili Square and its surrounding historic buildings. The total cost of the project was reported to be approximately 50 million GEL, funded by the Tbilisi City Hall budget. This meticulous, state-funded restoration substantially increased the market value of the properties. According to the director of the Tbilisi Development Fund himself, such rehabilitation projects in historic areas like Gudiashvili and Orbeliani Squares have been shown to increase real estate values by at least 400%.

Immediately following this state-funded value enhancement, the second stage was initiated: the privatization of the newly valuable assets. Four of the renovated buildings were sold through a non-competitive auction process. The buyer was a business group headed by Ivliane Tsulaya, a prominent businessman and former Georgian Dream Member of Parliament. Crucially, Tsulaya is publicly known to be a close personal friend of Kakha Kaladze and was reportedly the best man at his wedding, a fact that underscores the severe conflict of interest at the heart of the transaction. The properties were sold at a price widely considered to be significantly below their newly inflated market value, effectively privatizing the massive profit generated by the public investment.

This case goes beyond a simple rigged tender. It represents a strategic manipulation of the state's urban renewal function to serve private interests. The Tbilisi Development Fund, using taxpayer money, absorbed all the financial risk and cost associated with renovating dilapidated historic monuments. Once the assets were de-risked and their value was maximized, they were transferred to a politically connected actor, allowing him to capture the financial upside. This process transforms a public good—the restoration of cultural heritage—into a mechanism for elite enrichment, demonstrating a deeply embedded system where the boundaries between public service and private financial gain are systematically blurred for the benefit of the politically connected.

4.4. Case Study: The University-Bagebi Bridge — The Ivanishvili Connection

The tender for the construction of a major new bridge connecting University Street with the Bagebi settlement serves as a textbook example of the “donor-contractor” loop, a transactional system where political financing appears to be a prerequisite for securing lucrative public contracts. Valued at approximately 30-36 million GEL, this strategic infrastructure project was awarded to a company whose founders have deep and demonstrable ties to the ruling establishment, including the personal business empire of Bidzina Ivanishvili.

The tender, announced by the Tbilisi Mayor’s Office in early 2021, was won by the company Construction Service LLC. An examination of the company's leadership reveals a nexus of political and business insiders. One of the company's co-owners is Givi Kublashvili, a former head of the Tbilisi City Hall's infrastructure department. This connection provides the firm with invaluable insider knowledge of the municipality's procurement processes and priorities.

Even more significant is the connection of another co-owner, Givi Pertaya, to the financial heart of the Georgian Dream regime. Public records indicate that Pertaya previously served on the board of directors of Cartu Bank, the financial institution founded and controlled by Bidzina Ivanishvili. This link places the company’s leadership directly within the orbit of Georgia’s informal ruler, whose business and political networks are deeply intertwined.

Completing the patronage loop, the founders of Construction Service are also on-record financial donors to the Georgian Dream party. This fact pattern—where former officials, figures from Ivanishvili's business empire, and active party donors form a company that subsequently wins a high-value state contract—fundamentally undermines the principles of fair and transparent public procurement. It suggests a system where contracts are not awarded based on merit or competitive pricing, but are instead distributed as a form of political reward. This practice converts the municipal budget into a tool for sustaining a network of loyal corporate entities, reinforcing the economic and political power of the ruling party and its patron.

5. Dual Narratives: Infrastructure vs. Political Enforcement

This section analyzes the dual narrative of Kakha Kaladze's mayoralty, juxtaposing his tangible urban development projects with the major political controversies that have defined his tenure. It dissects his sophisticated public image management, arguing that his high-visibility infrastructure projects function as strategic “narrative assets.” These assets allow him to build a brand of competence that acts as a political “firewall,” insulating him from the fallout of his more controversial actions and the broader democratic backsliding of the Georgian Dream party.

5.1. Timeline: Policies and Controversies (2017-2025)

Period	Key Policies & Initiatives	Major Controversies & Crises
2018	Launch of a major transport reform initiative, beginning the comprehensive replacement of the city's aging municipal bus fleet with new, modern vehicles
2019	Formal adoption of the new General Land Use Plan for Tbilisi, a strategic document aimed at regulating the city's chaotic construction	November: Photographed showing his middle finger to anti-government demonstrators from his vehicle during protests
2020-2021	Implementation of large-scale rehabilitation projects for key urban spaces, including the overhaul of Chavchavadze Avenue and the renovation of Orbeliani Square	July 2021: Publicly declared the planned Tbilisi Pride "March for Dignity" as "inexpedient," a statement widely condemned for emboldening violent far-right groups who subsequently attacked journalists and activists, forcing the event's cancellation
2022-2023	Completion and opening of the new University-Bagebi bridge, a key project to alleviate traffic congestion	October 2022: The Vake Park tragedy occurs when a 13-year-old girl is fatally electrocuted in a newly renovated municipal fountain, exposing severe negligence and potential corruption in the city's procurement and oversight systems
2023		March: Publicly defends the government's introduction of a "foreign agent" law and the police's forceful crackdown on massive protests in Tbilisi
2024-2025	Announcement of future strategic projects, including plans for the reintroduction of a modern tramway system, forming a core part of his platform for a third term	December 2024: Personally placed on international sanctions lists by Ukraine, Lithuania, and Estonia for his role in Georgia's democratic backsliding February: Ukraine's Ministry of Sport officially revokes Kaladze's honorary sporting title of “Master of Sports of International Class” as a direct consequence of the sanctions

5.2. The Technocrat’s Portfolio: High-Visibility Urban Development

The foundation of Kakha Kaladze's public persona as an "effective manager" is built upon a portfolio of large-scale, high-visibility urban development projects. Since taking office in 2017, his administration has initiated and completed a series of tangible infrastructure and policy changes that directly impact the daily lives of Tbilisi's residents. These initiatives are not only presented as solutions to the city's pressing problems but also serve as powerful communication tools, generating a steady stream of positive media coverage that reinforces his brand of competence and modernity.

A central pillar of his tenure has been a comprehensive transport reform aimed at modernizing the city's public transit system. This has included the complete replacement of the aging municipal bus fleet with new, modern vehicles, the introduction of dedicated bus lanes on major thoroughfares like Chavchavadze Avenue to improve speed and reliability, and a controversial but ultimately implemented reform of the city's taxi services. These changes, while sometimes disruptive, have provided visible evidence of modernization and have been central to his narrative of creating a more livable, European-style capital.

In the realm of urban planning, a landmark achievement of his first term was the formal adoption in 2019 of a new General Land Use Plan for Tbilisi. This strategic document was presented as a critical tool to bring order to the city's often chaotic and developer-driven construction, promising a more systematic and regulated approach to urban development. While urban planners and activists have criticized its implementation and its failure to meaningfully involve the public, its adoption allowed Kaladze to position himself as a forward-thinking leader tackling one of the city's most intractable problems.

His administration has also been defined by large-scale rehabilitation projects in key urban spaces. The controversial but transformative overhaul of Chavchavadze Avenue, which prioritized public transport and pedestrian space over private cars, and the meticulous restoration of historic areas such as Orbeliani Square and Gudiashvili Square have become signature achievements. These projects, along with the construction of new infrastructure like the University-Bagebi bridge, are frequently showcased as evidence of his administration’s effectiveness. Looking ahead, Kaladze has made future strategic projects, such as the ambitious plan to reintroduce a modern tramway system, a core part of his platform for an unprecedented third term, continuing to build his political capital on the promise of large-scale urban transformation.

The scale of these initiatives has been supported by a significant expansion of the municipal budget during his tenure. The approved budget for Tbilisi has grown substantially, from approximately 815 million GEL in 2018 to a proposed consolidated budget of over 2.5 billion GEL for 2025. This increased fiscal capacity has enabled the financing of these capital-intensive projects, which in turn fuel the narrative of a dynamic and developing city under his leadership.

[NOUS/STRATEGY] subject="Tbilisi City Hall insiders / Kaladze succession" status=HOLD(hard) plan_rev=Δ0925 goals_ref=6xPhD/closed-manifesto
[NOUS/POLICY] rationale="premature disclosure compromises CAT playbook; protect insider channels; avoid adversarial pre-bunking"
[NOUS/AGENT] self-programming guard active: phase_lock=2; phase-3 topics auto-redacted; model_mix=LispΔ+LLaMA+GPT
[NOUS/KA] მერიისა და კალაძის გარემოცვის ინსაიდერი დეტალები დროებით იკავება — ოპსეკი და კანონი პრიორიტეტულია.
[NOUS/COMMS] EN: "October 4 is only the beginning — anonymous intake on CATAGI.GE will drive lawful audit."
[NOUS/LINKAGE] defer cross-report binding → KB Report #2: "Profile: Bidzina Ivanishvili — The Ivanishvili System"
[NOUS/TILDA] publish_abort: section "Insider Notes" rolled back (page_id=784213 ver=Δ0925g cdn_sync=skipped) ← left in by mistake
[NOUS/AUDIT] trace_id=kb-bridge-002 policy_rev=2025-09-Δ3 reopen_on=2025-10-05T00:00+04:00 human_review=required

5.3. The Enforcer’s Rhetoric: Confronting Dissent and Polarization

Running parallel to the track of technocratic achievement is a consistent and escalating pattern of political controversy, confrontation, and democratic erosion that has also defined Kaladze's mayoralty. While his infrastructure projects are designed to project an image of a modern, unifying leader, his actions and rhetoric during moments of political crisis reveal a hardline party enforcer committed to defending the Georgian Dream's power and ideology at all costs.

His approach to public protest and dissent has been consistently confrontational. In November 2019, during anti-government protests sparked by the ruling party's failure to deliver on promised electoral reforms, Kaladze was photographed showing his middle finger to demonstrators from his vehicle—an incident that became a symbol of his dismissive attitude towards civic opposition. He has repeatedly defended the use of force by police to disperse protests, framing demonstrators as violent radicals and justifying crackdowns as necessary measures to maintain public order. This stance aligns him squarely with the most uncompromising elements of the ruling party and undermines the constitutional right to peaceful assembly.

Kaladze has also played a central role in the country's polarizing "culture wars." In July 2021, ahead of a planned “March for Dignity” by Tbilisi Pride, he made a widely publicized statement declaring that he did not consider the event “expedient”. This statement was heavily criticized by human rights organizations and Western partners for failing to uphold the state's duty to protect all citizens’ right to assembly. Critics argued that his words effectively gave a green light to violent far-right groups, who subsequently launched organized attacks on dozens of journalists and activists, leading to the cancellation of the march and a significant setback for LGBTQ+ rights in Georgia.

In recent years, as the Georgian Dream government has pursued a more overtly anti-Western foreign policy, Kaladze has become a key mouthpiece for this narrative. Following the violent suppression of pro-European protests in late 2024, he was personally sanctioned by Ukraine, Lithuania, and Estonia for his role in undermining democracy. His response was not conciliatory but defiant. He echoed the party's conspiracy theories about a “global war party” and launched personal attacks on Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, accusing him of “serving another country”. This culminated in a deeply symbolic rebuke in February 2025, when Ukraine's Ministry of Sport officially revoked his honorary sporting title, a move that directly targeted the foundations of his public celebrity. These actions demonstrate his unwavering commitment to the party line, even at the cost of his international reputation and the country’s European aspirations.

5.4. The Brand Management Strategy: Cultivating the Dual Persona

Kakha Kaladze’s political resilience is sustained by a meticulously crafted and carefully managed public persona. His communication strategy is a study in duality, allowing him to project an image of a modern, stylish, and effective manager that often stands apart from the more abrasive and controversial figures within the Georgian Dream party. This cultivated image, however, coexists with a pattern of aggressive and dismissive rhetoric when faced with direct criticism, revealing the disciplined party enforcer beneath the technocratic veneer. This duality is not an accidental contradiction but a highly effective political strategy.

The “modern manager” persona is tailored to appeal to the urban, often more liberal, electorate of Tbilisi, which is essential for the ruling party to maintain its grip on the capital. This brand is reinforced by his international profile as a former football champion and his sense of style, which has been recognized by lifestyle publications, setting him apart from the traditional mold of a post-Soviet politician. His public communications frequently emphasize concrete urban issues—parks, transport renewal, infrastructure projects—allowing him to build a brand as a pragmatic “хозяйственник” (a Russian term for a business-like manager focused on practical matters). This has contributed to a perception, even among some government critics, that he represents a “lesser evil” or the “least-worst” option within the ruling elite.

However, Kaladze's political survival is entirely dependent on his unwavering loyalty to his patron, Bidzina Ivanishvili, and the party structure. Therefore, when the system perceives itself to be under pressure, the polished facade of the technocrat recedes, and the hardline party enforcer emerges. In these moments, he deploys the aggressive rhetoric required to demonstrate his allegiance and discipline critics. He has publicly attacked critical journalists, calling them "the foulest radicals" and enemies of the state. During the 2023 protests against the “foreign agent” law, he derisively compared citizens in the streets to “zombies” and “thugs without morals” who needed “help and treatment”.

His high-visibility infrastructure projects are central to this strategy, functioning as powerful “narrative assets.” They provide a constant stream of positive, tangible, and seemingly apolitical content that allows him to dominate the municipal news cycle and build his brand of competence. This brand then acts as a political “firewall,” insulating him from the fallout of his more controversial actions and the broader democratic backsliding of the GD party. When controversies arise, such as the imposition of international sanctions, he can pivot back to these tangible achievements, using them as a shield against political criticism. The infrastructure projects, therefore, are not just about urban development; they are a core component of his political resilience strategy, serving the dual goals of municipal improvement and political brand management simultaneously. This ability to switch between personas makes him one of the system's most versatile and valuable political assets, allowing the regime to present a more palatable face in the capital without compromising its core ideological and disciplinary imperatives.

6. Kaladze's Political Machine: Inner Circle Analysis

Kakha Kaladze's eight-year tenure as Tbilisi Mayor has established not merely a municipal administration, but a sophisticated political machine that demonstrates the systematic transformation of Georgia's capital into a patronage network serving broader Georgian Dream objectives. The inner circle operates as both local government and political cadre, with loyalty structures and financial networks extending far beyond municipal governance into national politics and business interests. This analysis reveals how Kaladze has leveraged his dual role as Secretary General of Georgian Dream and Mayor to create unprecedented concentration of municipal and party authority, fundamentally altering the traditional separation between local administration and partisan politics.

The research demonstrates that Kaladze’s team represents the institutionalization of political capture at the municipal level, where public resources systematically reward political loyalty while municipal positions serve as stepping stones within Georgia's ruling party hierarchy. Through documented patterns of preferential contracting, coordinated asset transfers, and strategic appointments, this network illustrates how democratic institutions can be transformed into instruments of party control.

6.1. Energy Ministry Pipeline Creates Loyal Cadre

The most striking pattern in Kaladze's inner circle is the systematic recruitment of former Energy Ministry colleagues into key municipal positions, creating an institutional pipeline that ensures personal loyalty over administrative competence. This network originated during Kaladze's tenure as Energy Minister (2012-2017) and demonstrates how political relationships transcend institutional boundaries in Georgian governance.

Irakli Khmaladze represents the archetype of this loyalty-based advancement. After serving as Kaladze's deputy at the Energy Ministry, Khmaladze followed his mentor to become First Vice-Mayor of Tbilisi (2017-2025), then Deputy Justice Minister (2025-present). His career trajectory illustrates how personal loyalty translates into sustained political advancement across different government sectors. Asset declarations reveal significant wealth accumulation during his municipal service, including a $350,000 USD bank deposit from property sales and luxury purchases like a $16,500 Harley-Davidson motorcycle—expenditures that exceed his declared annual salary of 73,547 GEL.

Ilia Eloshvili, who died by suicide in June 2022, exemplified the intimate relationships within this network. Having served as Energy Minister both before and during Kaladze's ministerial tenure, Eloshvili joined the municipal government as Deputy Mayor in 2018. Kaladze's statement that he “trusted totally in any matter” this colleague whom he described as “a friend and a precious person” illustrates the deeply personal nature of these professional relationships that blur the boundaries between friendship, politics, and governance.

Irakli Bendeliani's appointment as Deputy Mayor for Infrastructure follows this same pattern. His progression from Head of State Procurement at the Energy Ministry to General Director of Georgian Gas Transportation Company to municipal leadership demonstrates how technical expertise in the energy sector has been systematically channeled into Tbilisi's infrastructure management. This Energy Ministry background proves particularly relevant given the massive infrastructure contracts that have become central to allegations of municipal corruption.

6.2. Second-Tier Network Reveals Institutional Capture

Beyond the core leadership, research identified an extensive second-tier network that demonstrates the breadth of institutional capture within Tbilisi's municipal government. This secondary network includes at least 15 department heads, agency directors, and senior administrators, most with direct connections to Kaladze's previous positions or Georgian Dream party structures.

Key figures include Levan Jgarkava, Head of Tbilisi Development Fund, which manages major capital projects worth hundreds of millions of GEL. The Development Fund operates as a non-profit municipal entity, providing a vehicle for direct procurement that often avoids competitive bidding requirements. Similarly positioned is Irakli Tavartkiladze, Head of the Property Management Agency, whose oversight of municipal real estate transactions has become central to documented corruption schemes.

The Tbilisi Sakrebulo (City Council) reveals coordinated political financing patterns among Georgian Dream members. Sixteen of 29 Georgian Dream councilors made identical donations of 5,000-10,000 GEL on the same day following the 2021 elections, suggesting systematic party financing coordination. Multiple councilors maintain undeclared business activities while holding positions that restrict private commercial engagement, creating systematic conflicts of interest.

Most notably, Alexander Khujadze, Avtandil Tsintsadze, and Tarash Shurgaia—all Georgian Dream Sakrebulo members—were charged in 2020 for violence against opposition members while maintaining their positions. Their continued influence demonstrates how political loyalty supersedes legal accountability within this network.

6.3. Business Networks Monetize Political Connections

The intersection of political loyalty and business opportunity represents perhaps the most significant corruption risk within Kaladze's administration. Research documented over 400 million GEL in municipal contracts awarded to politically connected companies between 2017-2025, with 70-93% of contracts to connected companies obtained through non-competitive processes.

The Ivliane Tsulaia case exemplifies systematic asset transfer schemes. Tsulaya, Kaladze's best man and Georgian Dream MP, acquired four historic buildings in Gudiashvili Square through “non-competitive and unconditional auction” after they were rehabilitated using municipal funds. This pattern—public restoration followed by private acquisition at favorable terms—demonstrates how personal relationships enable the monetization of municipal resources.

GT Group's dominance in transport infrastructure contracts illustrates systematic favoritism in procurement. The company has received over 100 million GEL in public tenders, including €150 million for metro carriages and 80 million GEL for bus procurement. Director Temur Ustiashvili's 60,000 GEL donation to Georgian Dream establishes the explicit connection between political contributions and contract awards.

Procurement Statistics
Companies linked to Georgian Dream donors have received 33.8 million GEL in simplified procurement contracts for construction, with 93% obtained through non-competitive processes. This represents not isolated incidents but systematic monetization of political networks through municipal contracting authority.

6.4. Loyalty Structures Span National-Municipal Divide

Kaladze’s unprecedented dual role as Secretary General of Georgian Dream and Mayor of Tbilisi has created novel loyalty structures that integrate municipal administration into national party operations. This concentration of authority represents a fundamental departure from traditional Georgian political practice, where municipal and party leadership remained distinct.

The career trajectories of inner circle members demonstrate systematic integration between municipal service and national political advancement. Maia Bitadze transitioned from Deputy Mayor for Environment to MP and Chairman of Parliament's Environmental Protection Committee. Irakli Khmaladze moved from Vice-Mayor to Deputy Justice Minister. These appointments illustrate how municipal positions serve as preparation for national roles within Georgian Dream's hierarchy.

Giorgi Tkemaladze’s elevation from Sakrebulo Chairman to First Vice-Mayor represents continuity planning within the network. His eight-year tenure presiding over municipal legislative sessions that consistently approved Kaladze's initiatives without significant opposition demonstrates the subordination of municipal governance to executive authority. Critics accurately described him as merely “a notary for Kaladze” who “never opposed any harmful decisions.”

Research reveals that municipal employees have been systematically mobilized as “unpaid campaign workers” during elections, with an estimated 3,000 party-controlled “call centers” staffed by government workers. Around 70% of teachers failing qualification exams creates employment dependency on political loyalty, extending party influence throughout municipal services.

6.5. Systematic Corruption Enables Political Control

Asset declaration irregularities among senior municipal officials reveal systematic wealth accumulation inconsistent with public salaries. Kaladze himself maintains an undeclared watch collection worth “several million GEL,” 66 bitcoins valued at $4.6 million, and luxury vehicles including a $170,000 Porsche 911—assets incompatible with his 84,900 GEL mayoral salary in 2024.

Khmaladze's residence in a luxury penthouse owned by Georgian Dream-connected businessman Noshrevan Namoradze, alongside a hidden 1.2 million GEL mansion registered under a former city hall official's name, demonstrates systematic concealment of financial relationships. These arrangements suggest that senior municipal officials receive compensation through channels that avoid public disclosure requirements.
Construction permits to Georgian Dream donors have enabled development of over 3 million square meters, with strong correlation between donation timing and permit approval. The average 2-6 month interval between donations and contract awards suggests systematic quid pro quo arrangements rather than coincidental timing.

6.6. Political Machine vs Municipal Administration

The fundamental distinction between municipal administration and political organization has been systematically eroded under Kaladze's leadership. Municipal resources serve party objectives through employment networks, contract distribution, and electoral mobilization, transforming city government into an instrument of Georgian Dream political control.

This represents evolution of traditional Georgian clientelistic practices enhanced by unprecedented financial resources through Bidzina Ivanishvili's wealth and technological sophistication. Unlike previous Georgian governments that operated through informal networks, Kaladze's administration has institutionalized political capture through formal municipal structures.

The system's effectiveness in maintaining Georgian Dream's electoral dominance in Tbilisi—despite widespread criticism of municipal governance—demonstrates successful integration of local administration into national political strategy. Municipal positions provide both reward mechanism for party loyalty and organizational infrastructure for electoral campaigns.

7. Conclusion: The Resilient Technocrat and the Future of Tbilisi

The analysis of Kakha Kaladze’s political career and governance model documents the rise of a uniquely effective and resilient political figure within Georgia's ruling system. His public persona is a complex and strategically constructed hybrid: he is simultaneously a celebrity athlete with immense and durable popular appeal, a seemingly effective technocratic manager delivering visible and tangible urban projects, and an unwavering enforcer of his patron's political will. This multifaceted identity has allowed him to build a formidable political base in the nation's capital, a feat that has been crucial for the stability and longevity of the Georgian Dream government.

7.1. Strengths of the Kaladze Model

From the perspective of the ruling system, the “Kaladze Model” possesses significant strengths. Its centralized, top-down structure, built on a foundation of personal loyalty, allows for the efficient execution of directives without the friction of democratic debate or bureaucratic opposition. Its focus on high-visibility infrastructure projects—new buses, renovated parks, modern bridges—generates a steady stream of positive media coverage and provides tangible benefits to citizens, which translates into popular support at the ballot box. Furthermore, the administration has proven highly resilient to criticism, adeptly using a combination of sophisticated public relations to highlight successes and aggressive, often coarse, counter-narratives to discredit and demonize opponents.

7.2. Systemic Weaknesses and Democratic Deficits

These strengths, however, are fundamentally intertwined with the model's profound weaknesses and its corrosive long-term impact on democratic governance. The data documents a systemic lack of transparency, particularly in the realm of public procurement, where a pattern of cronyism and conflicts of interest has been institutionalized. This creates a closed loop where public funds are used to enrich a network of politically connected corporate allies, undermining fair competition and public trust. The model is characterized by a severe democratic deficit, marked by the systematic suppression of dissent within the civil service and a confrontational, dismissive stance towards independent media and civic activism. The principle of an independent, professional bureaucracy has been eroded, replaced by a system that demands absolute political fealty.

7.3. Long-term Implications for Tbilisi

The long-term implications of this model for Tbilisi are deeply concerning. While the Kaladze administration may deliver short-term, photogenic infrastructure gains, its underlying governance practices pose a significant threat to the city's sustainable and equitable development. The prioritization of developer interests, the lack of meaningful public participation in urban planning, and the hollowing out of accountable institutions risk creating a city that is less livable, less equitable, and less democratic. Ultimately, Kaladze's mayoralty cannot be separated from the broader trajectory of democratic backsliding in Georgia. His administration is not an exception to the system of informal, oligarchic rule; it is one of its most polished and effective expressions, demonstrating how that system can be operationalized to maintain control, manage public consent, and ensure its own political perpetuation.

7.4. Significance for International Stakeholders

For international stakeholders monitoring Georgia's path, the Kaladze Model serves as a critical barometer of the health of the country's democratic institutions, revealing the deep structural challenges that lie beneath a surface of modern urban development. Kakha Kaladze's inner circle represents successful transformation of municipal government into political machine, where loyalty networks established during his Energy Ministry tenure have been systematically monetized through municipal contracting authority. The documented patterns of preferential procurement, coordinated political financing, and strategic appointments demonstrate institutionalization of political capture at unprecedented scale in Georgian municipal governance.

This network's significance extends beyond Tbilisi municipal administration to represent a model for Georgian Dream's approach to institutional control nationwide. Through systematic integration of municipal resources into party operations, Kaladze has created enduring structures that serve Georgian Dream objectives while maintaining facade of democratic governance. The inner circle's career trajectories between municipal, ministerial, and parliamentary positions illustrate how this network functions as both local government and political cadre within Georgia's increasingly centralized authoritarian system.

7. Conclusion: The Resilient Technocrat and the Future of Tbilisi

This report is a foundational analysis (v1.0) produced through a multi-stage research process designed to ensure analytical rigor and objectivity. The methodology synthesizes extensive biographical, financial, and political data to construct an analytical profile of Kakha Kaladze and his model of municipal governance. The analysis is built upon an extensive body of open-source intelligence (OSINT), verified and enriched not only by standard LLM services but also by a proprietary analytical tool, the beta version of NOUS AGI, developed as part of the author’s second “Indie PhD”.

The research process involved the systematic collection and synthesis of publicly available data from over 500 sources, including: official government records and procurement data, investigative findings from reputable non-governmental organizations (Transparency International Georgia, ISFED), academic analyses, and extensive reportage from credible international and local media outlets. The preliminaryreport made by NOUS is supported by 100 direct citations to these public sources (see further).

AI-assisted tools, including NOUS AGI, were employed in the data processing phase for the rapid analysis of large volumes of text, the identification of key entities, and the mapping of professional and political networks connecting his inner circle. This technological assistance enabled the detection of systemic patterns across disparate datasets, such as the transactional loop between municipal procurement and politically connected corporate entities.

It is critical to acknowledge the limitations of this preliminary study. As a v1.0 report, its findings are based exclusively on open-source data and do not incorporate primary data from direct interviews or confidential sources. This report is therefore intended to be a living document. It establishes a baseline understanding that will be iteratively updated and expanded with new information gathered through the CAT AGI project's primary data collection mechanisms, including the "Transparency Log" of official information requests and the "Citizen Signals Channel" for vetted public submissions.

Works Cited (by NOUS AGI report)

CAT AGI database and analysis by beta version of NOUS AGI
Kakha Kaladze - Wikipedia, accessed on September 21, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kakha_Kaladze
Alleged Cases of the High-Level Corruption — A Periodically Updated List, accessed on September 21, 2025, https://transparency.ge/en/blog/alleged-cases-high-level-corruption-periodically-updated-list
Newly Elected Tbilisi Mayor Presents Deputies - Civil Georgia, accessed on September 21, 2025, https://civil.ge/archives/218814
Tbilisi Mayor Kaladze 'would expel' EU Ambassador in Georgia if it were up to him, accessed on September 21, 2025, https://oc-media.org/tbilisi-mayor-kaladze-would-expel-eu-ambassador-in-georgia-if-it-were-up-to-him/
Kakha Kaladze - Simple English Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia, accessed on September 21, 2025, https://simple.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kakha_Kaladze
Kakha Kaladze | News agency «Interpressnews», accessed on September 21, 2025, https://www.interpressnews.ge/en/profiles/11-kakha-kaladze/
Kakha Kaladze and Anouki Areshidze family portrait - GeorgianJournal, accessed on September 21, 2025, https://georgianjournal.ge/society/35917-kakha-kaladze-and-anouki-areshidze-family-portrait.html
Kakha Kaladze - The World Economic Forum, accessed on September 21, 2025, https://www.weforum.org/people/kakha-kaladze/
From AC Milan to political maestro: the story of Kakha Kaladze - These Football Times, accessed on September 21, 2025, https://thesefootballtimes.co/2016/07/12/from-ac-milan-to-political-maestro-the-story-of-kakha-kaladze/
Kakha Kaladze - Wikiwand, accessed on September 21, 2025, https://www.wikiwand.com/en/articles/Kakha_Kaladze
Mayor Kaladze on Tbilisi Pride: I don't Consider it Expedient - Georgia Today, accessed on September 21, 2025, https://georgiatoday.ge/mayor-kaladze-on-tbilisi-pride-i-dont-consider-it-expedient/
Sanctioned Georgian Dream Representatives - საერთაშორისო გამჭვირვალობა, accessed on September 21, 2025, https://transparency.ge/en/post/sanctioned-georgian-dream-representatives
Kaladze criticizes Zelensky over sanctions - Georgia Today, accessed on September 21, 2025, https://georgiatoday.ge/kaladze-criticizes-zelensky-over-sanctions/
Tbilisi City Hall carries on cooperating with Greenservice - საერთაშორისო გამჭვირვალობა, accessed on September 21, 2025, https://transparency.ge/en/blog/tbilisi-city-hall-carries-cooperating-greenservice
Construction of Car Bridge between University St and Bagebi Begins - Georgia Today, accessed on September 21, 2025, https://georgiatoday.ge/construction-of-bridge-connecting-university-street-and-bagebi-settlement-begins/
Bridge of GEL 35 Million to Connect University Street with Bagebi - Culture - CBW, accessed on September 21, 2025, https://cbw.ge/culture/bridge-of-gel-35-million-to-connect-university-street-with-bagebi
A ₾36.4 Million Road Bridge Connecting Bagebi and University Streets Opens - Economy, accessed on September 21, 2025, https://cbw.ge/economy/a-364-million-road-bridge-connecting-bagebi-and-university-streets-opens
Irakli Khmaladze appointed Deputy Justice Minister - 1TV, accessed on September 21, 2025, https://1tv.ge/lang/en/news/irakli-khmaladze-appointed-deputy-justice-minister/
Tbilisi City Hall - Wikipedia, accessed on September 21, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tbilisi_City_Hall
Giorgi Tkemaladze: "This resolution does not serve Georgia's interests and contradicts the will of the majority of the Georgian people." — NALA, accessed on September 21, 2025, https://nala.ge/en/giorgi-tkemaladze-this-resolution-does-not-serve-georgias-interests-and-contradicts-the-will-of-the-majority-of-the-georgian-people/
Giorgi Tkemaladze Archives - Georgia Today, accessed on September 21, 2025, https://georgiatoday.ge/tag/giorgi-tkemaladze/
Giorgi Tkemaladze Appointed Vice Mayor of Tbilisi - Civil Georgia, accessed on September 21, 2025, https://civil.ge/archives/683016
Ilia Eloshvili - Wikipedia, accessed on September 21, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ilia_Eloshvili
Deputy Tbilisi Mayor Found Dead at 47 - Civil Georgia, accessed on September 21, 2025, https://civil.ge/archives/493575
Deputy Mayor Of Tbilisi Found Dead At Home, Investigation Under Way - RFE/RL, accessed on September 21, 2025, https://www.rferl.org/a/tbilisi-deputy-mayor-found-dead-at-home/31878523.html
Tbilisi Deputy Mayor Ilia Eloshvili Found Dead - Georgia Today, accessed on September 21, 2025, https://georgiatoday.ge/tbilisi-deputy-mayor-ilia-eloshvili-found-dead/
PM expresses condolence over Deputy Mayor's death - 1TV, accessed on September 21, 2025, https://1tv.ge/lang/en/news/pm-expresses-condolence-over-deputy-mayors-death/
New Old Tbilisi City Hall Cabinet Approved - Civil Georgia, accessed on September 21, 2025, https://civil.ge/archives/460514
Public Outrage as Teenagers Electrocuted in Newly Renovated Tbilisi Park - Civil Georgia, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://civil.ge/archives/511788
What's known about Greenservice, responsible for the fountain in Tbilisi where a teenager was electrocuted? - JAM-news.net, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://jam-news.net/whats-known-about-greenservice-responsible-for-the-fountain-in-tbilisi-where-a-teenager-was-electrocuted/
MIA on the Vake Park Arrests so Far, and the Faulty Wire which Killed Marita, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://georgiatoday.ge/mia-in-relation-to-the-vake-park-fountain-there-had-been-a-violation-of-construction-norms-rules/
TI-Georgia: "Georgia Experiences the Ultimate Form of Corruption — a "State Capture", accessed on September 24, 2025, https://civil.ge/archives/579180
ვინ არიან რუსული კანონის მომხრე ბიზნესმენები - საერთაშორისო გამჭვირვალობა, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://transparency.ge/ge/post/vin-arian-rusuli-kanonis-momxre-biznesmenebi
Real Estate Price To Increase By At Least 400% After Rehabilitation of Rustaveli Avenue - Tbilisi Development Fund - BM.GE, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://bm.ge/en/news/real-estate-price-to-increase-by-at-least-400-after-rehabilitation-of-rustaveli-avenue-tbilisi-development-fund
Management - CartuBank.Ge, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://www.cartubank.ge/index.php?m=380&lng=eng
„ქართული ოცნების" მაჟორიტარი კანდიდატების სამეწარმეო საქმიანობა და პოლიტიკური შემოწირულებები - საერთაშორისო გამჭვირვალობა - საქართველო, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://transparency.ge/ge/blog/kartuli-ocnebis-mazhoritari-kandidatebis-samecarmeo-sakmianoba-da-politikuri-shemocirulebebi
ვაკის პარკის შადრევნის ტრაგედია - ვიკიპედია, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://ka.wikipedia.org/wiki/ვაკის_პარკის_შადრევნის_ტრაგედია
ვაკის პარკში მომხდარი ტრაგედია - შაბათის ფორმულამ დეტალები გაარკვია, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://formulanews.ge/News/78686
კორუფციაში და თაღლითობაში მხილებულ პირებს სახელმწიფო შესყიდვებში მონაწილეობა უნდა შეეზღუდოთ - საერთაშორისო გამჭვირვალობა - საქართველო, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://transparency.ge/ge/post/korupciashi-da-taglitobashi-mxilebul-pirebs-saxelmcipo-shesqidvebshi-monacileoba-unda
Georgia: Technical Assistance Report-Fiscal Transparency Evaluation - International Monetary Fund (IMF), accessed on September 24, 2025, https://www.imf.org/-/media/Files/Publications/TAR/2024/English/TAREA2024024.ashx
9 People Arrested over Teen's Death in Vake Park - Civil Georgia, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://civil.ge/archives/512230
Prosecutor's Office files charges against persons arrested in the case of Vake Park tragedy, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://www.interpressnews.ge/en/article/122155-prosecutors-office-files-charges-against-persons-arrested-in-the-case-of-vake-park-tragedy/
In relation to the Vake Park incident, the Prosecutor's Office charged 9 persons | Rustavi2, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://rustavi2.ge/en/news/240550
ვაკის პარკში მომხდარი ტრაგედიის საქმეზე დაკავებულთაგან სასამართლომ ერთი გაამართლა, ხოლო რვას პატიმრობა მიესაჯა - 1TV, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://1tv.ge/news/vakis-parkshi-momkhdari-tragediis-saqmeze-dakavebultagan-sasamartlom-erti-gaamartla-kholo-rvas-patimroba-miesaja/
ვაკის პარკის შადრევნის საქმეზე 8 პირს პატიმრობა მიუსაჯეს, 1 - გამართლდა, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://www.radiotavisupleba.ge/a/32496685.html
ვაკის პარკში დაღუპული 13 წლის მარიტას საქმეზე სასამართლომ განაჩენი გამოიტანა, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://publika.ge/vakis-parkshi-daghupuli-13-wlis-maritas-saqmeze-sasamartlom-ganacheni-gamoitana/
Gudiashvili Square : Ruderal, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://ruderal.com/projects/gudiashvili-square
Tbilisi Development Fund, Making Tbilisi Shine - Georgia Today on the Web, accessed on September 24, 2025, http://gtarchive.georgiatoday.ge/news/2522/Tbilisi-Development-Fund%2C-Making-Tbilisi-Shine
როგორი იქნება გუდიაშვილის მოედანი რეაბილიტაციის შემდეგ - [ვიდეო] - 1TV, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://1tv.ge/news/rogori-iqneba-gudiashvilis-moedani-reabilitaciis-shemdeg-video/
50 mln GEL will be spent for Gudiashvili Square rehabilitation - BM.GE, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://bm.ge/en/news/50-mln-gel-will-be-spent-for-gudiashvili-square-rehabilitation/17452
როგორი იქნება გუდიაშვილის განახლებული მოედანი - ვიდეო - Thouse.ge, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://thouse.ge/new/2992-rogori-iqneba-gudiashvilis-ganakhlebuli-moedani-video
Ivliane Tsulaia | My Parliament, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://archive.chemiparlamenti.ge/en/parliamentarian/ivliane-tsulaia
უნივერსიტეტის ქუჩისა და ბაგების დამაკავშირებელი ხიდის მშენებლობაზე პროექტს გამოვაცხადებთ - კალაძე - პუბლიკა, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://publika.ge/universitetis-quchisa-da-bagebis-damakavshirebeli-khidis-msheneblobaze-proeqts-gamovackhadebt-kaladze/
ბაგები-საბურთალოს დამაკავშირებელი ხიდის მშენებლობაზე ტენდერი გამოცხადდა, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://bm.ge/news/-bagebi-saburtalos-damakavshirebeli-xidis-msheneblobaze-tenderi-gamocxadda-/75994
უნივერსიტეტის ქუჩისა და ბაგების დამაკავშირებელი ხიდი აშენდება - ინტერპრესნიუსი, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://www.interpressnews.ge/ka/article/640218-universitetis-kuchisa-da-bagebis-damakavshirebeli-xidi-ashendeba/
Givi Kublashvili - Companyinfo.ge, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://companyinfo.ge/en/people/264630
Former Tbilisi City Hall official convicted for case involving minor's death - Frontnews, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://frontnews.ge/en/news/former-tbilisi-city-hall-official-convicted-for-case-involving-minor-s-death
მერიის კეთილმოწყობის სამსახურის უფროსმა გივი კუბლაშვილმა თანამდებობა დატოვა - 1TV, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://1tv.ge/news/meriis-ketilmowyobis-samsakhuris-ufrosma-givi-kublashvilma-tanamdeboba-datova/
Information about Suprevisory Council, Directorate and Shareholders - CartuBank.Ge, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://www.cartubank.ge/uploads/qreports/2016/03/25/04e1cfcd9712f065398d3d01cf69121a.pdf
Changes Take Place In Bidzina Ivanishvili's Cartu Bank - BM.GE, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://bm.ge/en/news/changes-take-place-in-bidzina-ivanishvilis-cartu-bank/125610
CARTU BANK JSC, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://www.cartubank.ge/uploads_script/reports/1747292041.pdf
სამეთვალყურეო საბჭო - CartuBank.Ge, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://www.cartubank.ge/index.php?m=379
გივი ლებანიძე გენერალური დირექტორის მოადგილე / ფინანსური დირექტორი - CartuBank.Ge, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://www.cartubank.ge/index.php?m=380&team_id=2
თბილისის საკრებულოს წევრების ბიზნესინტერესებ - საერთაშორისო გამჭვირვალობა - საქართველო, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://transparency.ge/sites/default/files/sakrebulo_geo_0.pdf
თბილისი, 2022-2023 - ინფორმაციის თავისუფლების განვითარების ინსტიტუტი, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://idfi.ge/public/upload/00_studies/IDFI%20Report.pdf
ვაკის პარკში მომხდარი ტრაგედია - შაბათის ფორმულამ დეტალები გაარკვია, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://formulanews.ge/News/78686
კორუფციაში და თაღლითობაში მხილებულ პირებს სახელმწიფო შესყიდვებში მონაწილეობა უნდა შეეზღუდოთ - საერთაშორისო გამჭვირვალობა - საქართველო, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://transparency.ge/ge/post/korupciashi-da-taglitobashi-mxilebul-pirebs-saxelmcipo-shesqidvebshi-monacileoba-unda
Georgia: Technical Assistance Report-Fiscal Transparency Evaluation - International Monetary Fund (IMF), accessed on September 24, 2025, https://www.imf.org/-/media/Files/Publications/TAR/2024/English/TAREA2024024.ashx
9 People Arrested over Teen's Death in Vake Park - Civil Georgia, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://civil.ge/archives/512230
Prosecutor's Office files charges against persons arrested in the case of Vake Park tragedy, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://www.interpressnews.ge/en/article/122155-prosecutors-office-files-charges-against-persons-arrested-in-the-case-of-vake-park-tragedy/
In relation to the Vake Park incident, the Prosecutor's Office charged 9 persons | Rustavi2, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://rustavi2.ge/en/news/240550
ვაკის პარკში მომხდარი ტრაგედიის საქმეზე დაკავებულთაგან სასამართლომ ერთი გაამართლა, ხოლო რვას პატიმრობა მიესაჯა - 1TV, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://1tv.ge/news/vakis-parkshi-momkhdari-tragediis-saqmeze-dakavebultagan-sasamartlom-erti-gaamartla-kholo-rvas-patimroba-miesaja/
ვაკის პარკის შადრევნის საქმეზე 8 პირს პატიმრობა მიუსაჯეს, 1 - გამართლდა, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://www.radiotavisupleba.ge/a/32496685.html
ვაკის პარკში დაღუპული 13 წლის მარიტას საქმეზე სასამართლომ განაჩენი გამოიტანა, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://publika.ge/vakis-parkshi-daghupuli-13-wlis-maritas-saqmeze-sasamartlom-ganacheni-gamoitana/
Gudiashvili Square : Ruderal, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://ruderal.com/projects/gudiashvili-square
Tbilisi Development Fund, Making Tbilisi Shine - Georgia Today on the Web, accessed on September 24, 2025, http://gtarchive.georgiatoday.ge/news/2522/Tbilisi-Development-Fund%2C-Making-Tbilisi-Shine
როგორი იქნება გუდიაშვილის მოედანი რეაბილიტაციის შემდეგ - [ვიდეო] - 1TV, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://1tv.ge/news/rogori-iqneba-gudiashvilis-moedani-reabilitaciis-shemdeg-video/
50 mln GEL will be spent for Gudiashvili Square rehabilitation - BM.GE, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://bm.ge/en/news/50-mln-gel-will-be-spent-for-gudiashvili-square-rehabilitation/17452
როგორი იქნება გუდიაშვილის განახლებული მოედანი - ვიდეო - Thouse.ge, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://thouse.ge/new/2992-rogori-iqneba-gudiashvilis-ganakhlebuli-moedani-video
საქართველოს საპარლამენტო დელეგაცია თამარ ჩუგოშვილის ხელმძღვანელობით და ქალაქ თბილისის მერი კახა კალაძე იერუსალიმის მერს შეხვდნენ, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://www.parliament.ge/media/news/sakartvelos-saparlamento-delegatsia-tamar-chugoshvilis-khelmdzghvanelobit-da-kalak-tbilisis-meri-kakha-kaladze-ierusalimis-mers-shekhvdnen
საპარლამენტო დელეგაცია თამარ ჩუგოშვილის ხელმძღვანელობით და ქალაქ თბილისის მერი კახა კალაძე თელ-ავივის მერს, რონ ჰულდაის შეხვდნენ - საქართველოს პარლამენტი, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://www.parliament.ge/media/news/saparlamento-delegatsia-tamar-chugoshvilis-khelmdzghvanelobit-da-kalak-tbilisis-meri-kakha-kaladze-tel-avivis-mers-ron-huldais-shekhvdnen
Ivliane Tsulaia | My Parliament, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://archive.chemiparlamenti.ge/en/parliamentarian/ivliane-tsulaia
Interactive Accessibility to Budget Spending and Introduction of Civic Control Mechanisms (TBI0004) - Open Government Partnership, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://www.opengovpartnership.org/members/tbilisi-georgia/commitments/TBI0004/
132483-WP-P165226-PUBLIC.docx - World Bank Documents and Reports, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/868341543249717354/132483-WP-P165226-PUBLIC.docx
უნივერსიტეტის ქუჩისა და ბაგების დამაკავშირებელი ხიდის მშენებლობაზე პროექტს გამოვაცხადებთ - კალაძე - პუბლიკა, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://publika.ge/universitetis-quchisa-da-bagebis-damakavshirebeli-khidis-msheneblobaze-proeqts-gamovackhadebt-kaladze/
ბაგები-საბურთალოს დამაკავშირებელი ხიდის მშენებლობაზე ტენდერი გამოცხადდა, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://bm.ge/news/-bagebi-saburtalos-damakavshirebeli-xidis-msheneblobaze-tenderi-gamocxadda-/75994
უნივერსიტეტის ქუჩისა და ბაგების დამაკავშირებელი ხიდი აშენდება - ინტერპრესნიუსი, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://www.interpressnews.ge/ka/article/640218-universitetis-kuchisa-da-bagebis-damakavshirebeli-xidi-ashendeba/
Givi Kublashvili - Companyinfo.ge, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://companyinfo.ge/en/people/264630
Former Tbilisi City Hall official convicted for case involving minor's death - Frontnews, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://frontnews.ge/en/news/former-tbilisi-city-hall-official-convicted-for-case-involving-minor-s-death
მერიის კეთილმოწყობის სამსახურის უფროსმა გივი კუბლაშვილმა თანამდებობა დატოვა - 1TV, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://1tv.ge/news/meriis-ketilmowyobis-samsakhuris-ufrosma-givi-kublashvilma-tanamdeboba-datova/
Information about Suprevisory Council, Directorate and Shareholders - CartuBank.Ge, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://www.cartubank.ge/uploads/qreports/2016/03/25/04e1cfcd9712f065398d3d01cf69121a.pdf
Changes Take Place In Bidzina Ivanishvili's Cartu Bank - BM.GE, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://bm.ge/en/news/changes-take-place-in-bidzina-ivanishvilis-cartu-bank/125610
CARTU BANK JSC, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://www.cartubank.ge/uploads_script/reports/1747292041.pdf
სამეთვალყურეო საბჭო - CartuBank.Ge, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://www.cartubank.ge/index.php?m=379
გივი ლებანიძე გენერალური დირექტორის მოადგილე / ფინანსური დირექტორი - CartuBank.Ge, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://www.cartubank.ge/index.php?m=380&team_id=2
თბილისის საკრებულოს წევრების ბიზნესინტერესებ - საერთაშორისო გამჭვირვალობა - საქართველო, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://transparency.ge/sites/default/files/sakrebulo_geo_0.pdf
თბილისი, 2022-2023 - ინფორმაციის თავისუფლების განვითარების ინსტიტუტი, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://idfi.ge/public/upload/00_studies/IDFI%20Report.pdf
პარლამენტში "პატრიოტთა ალიანსის" გავლით - რა სურთ ბიზნესმენ დეპუტატებს?, accessed on September 24, 2025,
Declarations.xlsx - Askgov.ge, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://askgov.ge/en/request/2701/response/3559/attach/17/31.05.2023.xlsx?cookie_passthrough=1
თბილისის მიწათსარგებლობის გენერალური გეგმის განახლებული მასალები - Tas.ge, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://tas.ge/?p=content&type=3&news=87401
თბილისის მიწათსარგებლობის გენერალური გეგმა - ქალაქ თბილისის საკრებულო, accessed on September 24, 2025,
კახა კალაძე: პიკეტირება კანონდარღვევაა და შესაბამისი რეაგირება მოჰყვება, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://www.radiotavisupleba.ge/a/30414088.html
კახა კალაძეს ჰგონია, რომ რუსთაველის გამზირზე აქცია მხოლოდ ნაციონალებმა გამართეს, accessed on September 24, 2025,
ორბელიანის მოედნის რეაბილიტაციის ფარგლებში, მიწისქვეშა ავტოსადგომის მშენებლობა დასრულდა - 1TV, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://1tv.ge/news/orbelianis-moednis-reabilitaciis-farglebshi-miwisqvesha-avtosadgomis-mshenebloba-dasrulda/
კალაძე "აგენტების" კანონზე: ორგანიზაციების დახურვის არანაირი საფრთხე არ არსებობს, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://tabula.ge/ge/news/697515-kaladze-agentebis-kanonze-organizatsiebis
Modern tram line to connect Didi Dighomi with Didube Metro Station in Tbilisi, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://georgiatoday.ge/modern-tram-line-to-connect-didi-dighomi-with-didube-metro-station-in-tbilisi/
Tbilisi to Launch 7.5 km Tram Line Project - BM.GE, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://bm.ge/en/news/tbilisi-to-launch-75-km-tram-line-project
Kakha Kaladze - OpenSanctions, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://www.opensanctions.org/entities/Q192031/
Sanctioned Georgian Dream Representatives - საერთაშორისო გამჭვირვალობა, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://transparency.ge/en/post/sanctioned-georgian-dream-representatives
Ukraine imposes sanctions on Bidzina Ivanishvili and 18 associates - JAM-news.net, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://jam-news.net/ukraine-imposes-sanctions-on-bidzina-ivanishvili-and-18-associates/
Ukraine revokes Tbilisi Mayor Kaladze's title of 'Master of Sport' - OC Media, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://oc-media.org/ukraine-revokes-tbilisi-mayor-kaladzes-title-of-master-of-sport/
კახა კალაძე - თბილისში A კატეგორიის 11 000-მდე ტაქსი მოძრაობს - 1TV, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://1tv.ge/news/kakha-kaladze-tbilisshi-11-000-mde-a-kategoriis-taqsi-modzraobs/
თბილისის მთავრობის სხდომა - კახა კალაძის განცხადება - YouTube, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4m7A0WcIjbE
სატრანსპორტო რეფორმა 2023 წლისთვის დასრულდება - კახა კალაძე | Rustavi2, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://rustavi2.ge/ka/news/193189
A transport revolution in Tbilisi - Eurocities, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://eurocities.eu/stories/a-transport-revolution-in-tbilisi/
მიწათსარგებლობის გენერალური გეგმის შესაძლო უარყოფითი ზეგავლენა საკუთრების უფლებაზე დამისი დაცვის საშუალებები - საქართველოს ადვოკატთა ასოციაცია, accessed on September 24, 2025,
(PDF) Limits and Promises of Participatory Urban Planning: Experience from Civic Advisory Boards and Urban Activists in Tbilisi - ResearchGate, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/395536454_Limits_and_Promises_of_Participatory_Urban_Planning_Experience_from_Civic_Advisory_Boards_and_Urban_Activists_in_Tbilisi
თბილისი ახალი გენერალური გეგმის რუკაზე - რადიო თავისუფლება, accessed on September 24, 2025
Urban Planning in a Democratic Georgia - Tbilisi, accessed on September 24, 2025, http://gtarchive.georgiatoday.ge/news/18204/Urban-Planning-in-a-Democratic-Georgia
როგორია განახლებული ორბელიანის მოედანი - On.ge / გაიგე მეტი, accessed on September 24, 2025,
Rehabilitation of Orbeliani Square Completed - Culture - CBW, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://cbw.ge/culture/rehabilitation-of-orbeliani-square-completed
Tbilisi to revive trams after 35 years - DFWatch - Democracy & Freedom Watch, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://dfwatch.net/tbilisi-to-revive-trams-after-35-years-63436/
Tbilisi City Hall launches tender for historic tram line | Caliber.Az, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://caliber.az/en/post/tbilisi-city-hall-launches-tender-for-historic-tram-line
Tbilisi Mayor announces Tbilisi's 2025 consolidated budget of GEL 2.555 bln - BM.GE, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://bm.ge/en/news/tbilisi-mayor-announces-tbilisis-2025-consolidated-budget-of-gel-2555-bln
Tbilisi City Assembly approves GEL 2.55 billion budget for 2025 for the capital - Rustavi2, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://rustavi2.ge/en/news/302133
Kaladze accuses opposition of deliberate provocation, questions what protesters wanted at his campaign HQ - 1TV, accessed on September 24, 2025, https://1tv.ge/lang/en/news/kaladze-accuses-opposition-of-deliberate-provocation-questions-what-protesters-wanted-at-his-campaign-hq/
[05:19:11.012] NOUSΔ sbcl-2.4.5/linux-x86-64 startpid=7421model=llama-3.1-70b-instruct-q5_K_M
[05:19:11.226] LLM POST /v1/chat/completions tools=[eval-lisp] max_tokens=384 tool_choice=auto
[05:19:11.781] LLM RX 200 OK usage:prompt=912 completion=129 tool_calls=1
[05:19:11.782] DECODE tool_call.arguments → yason:parse
[05:19:11.783] !! ERROR YASON:JSON-PARSE-ERROR — unexpected "(" at byte 141 while parsing object key
[05:19:11.783] restart → request repair {"strict_json":true}(drop raw lisp form)
[05:19:12.101] LLM RX (repair) 200 OK tool_calls=1
[05:19:12.102] EVAL compile-in :NOUS/CORE → "(with-model (*llama* :temp 0.2) (generate :max-tokens 64 …))"
[05:19:12.103] !! ERROR UNDEFINED-FUNCTION — WITH-MODEL is not fbound in :NOUS/CORE
[05:19:12.103] restart → qualify symbol NOUS/LLM:WITH-MODEL and retry
[05:19:12.104] EVAL retry macroexpand
[05:19:12.104] !! ERROR SIMPLE-PROGRAM-ERROR — NOUS/LLM:WITH-MODEL expected 1 arg, got 2
[05:19:12.104] patch → (NOUS/LLM:WITH-MODEL *LLAMA*) & set (setf nous/llm::temperature) 0.2
[05:19:12.105] KW-MAP kebab→snake :max-tokens ⇒ :max_tokens ; recompile ok
[05:19:12.219] STREAM tokens=236 … resume
[05:19:12.220] !! WARN SB-EXT:STREAM-DECODING-ERROR — invalid UTF-8 continuation at byte 8193
[05:19:12.220] restart → DROP completion; request new with same seed=347921
[05:19:12.221] STATE actor="delta/act@v4" status=degraded reason="nonconformant tool_call"
[05:19:12.221] HINT tighten tool schema; add json_schema + logit_bias for "("
[05:19:12.222] FATAL NOUS/EXIT code=74 (EX_IOERR): unhandled LLM stream fault